Quantification of sodium contaminant on steel surfaces using pulse CO2 laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy
Article History
-
Received: ,
Accepted: ,
Abstract
Corrosion is one of the main reasons for in-core accidents in liquid sodium-cooled fast reactors, especially accidents due to fuel cladding pipe damage. It is urgently required to investigate what kind of compound is produced as a corrosion product after the interaction between stainless steel and sodium in fast breeder reactors (FBR). In this work, the identification and quantification of sodium contaminant on steel surfaces has been conducted using laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy utilizing the specific characteristics of a pulse transversely excited atmospheric CO2 laser. Experimentally, a pulse TEA CO2 laser (Shibuya, 10.64 μm, 200 ns) was directed and bombarded onto the sodium contaminant deposited on the surface of stainless steel. An excellent emission spectrum of sodium from the contaminant was obtained without any disturbance from analytical lines from the steel itself. A quantification of sodium contaminant on the steel surface has been successfully made by a linear calibration curve obtained from steel containing various concentrations of sodium. The limit of detection of sodium on the metal surface was estimated to be 0.5 mg/kg. Also, a comparative sodium analysis study was qualitatively made by using LIBS utilizing a pulse Nd:YAG laser. The results demonstrate that the present technique of TEA CO2 LIBS is far superior to the case of Nd:YAG LIBS, as proven by an excellent emission spectrum of sodium with optimum intensity, and low noise and background emission.
Keywords
This article was originally published by Elsevier and was migrated to Scientific Scholar after the change of Publisher.
Peer review under responsibility of King Saud University.
1 Introduction
In fast breeder reactors, corrosion is a main reason behind accidents causing in-core damage in liquid sodium-cooled fast reactors, especially in fuel cladding pipes. Thus, it is important to investigate what kind of compound is produced as a corrosion product after the interaction between stainless steel and sodium (Na) (Sakamoto et al., 2013; Nguyen et al., 2020; Sofu, 2015). In fast reactors, the cladding and internal structures are made of steel, so the chemical reaction and coexistence of the steel with Na is an important issue (Hartanto et al., 2016; Schmidt et al., 2021; Velusamy, 2019). When Na reaction products that are formed on spent fuel rods and in-core structural components are found during a visual inspection, it is necessary to perform a quasi-non-destructive inspection to analyze the products. The problem of fuel roads and internal structures deposited with Na in fast reactors should be discussed with utilization of analytical spectroscopy for diagnostic technology for maintenance in FBRs.
Some spectroscopic methods have been introduced for the identification of impurity contaminants deposited on the surface of metal materials. Sodium ionization detectors have been developed and employed in liquid metal-cooled fast breeder reactors (Sylvia et al., 2012; Vijayakumar et al., 2011). The other techniques include differential pressure detectors, ionization chambers, and contact leak detectors (Praveen et al., 2017; Fourmentel et al., 2013). However, they require tedious sample pre-treatment and a great deal of work.
Laser induced breakdown spectroscopy (LIBS) has become an established analytical atomic spectroscopy technique for rapid and in-situ analysis in various kinds of samples, including liquid, solid, and gas, without complicated preparation (Jantzi et al., 2016; Galbács, 2015; Legnaioli et al., 2020; Yuan et al., 2019; Jiang et al., 2017). In LIBS, a pulse Nd:YAG laser is commonly employed as an energy source to induce a breakdown plasma in/on the material target. Due to its simple preparation and its ability to analyze simultaneously several elements in the material target, LIBS has been applied in various major fields such as medical, environmental, and industrial fields (Busser et al., 2018; Wang et al., 2020; Harmon et al., 2013; Yu et al., 2014; Su et al., xxxx). Some researchers used a surface-assisted LIBS technique for liquid analysis (Bockova et al., 2018). However, the LIBS technique cannot easily be employed to identify contaminant deposited on metal surfaces having spectral analytical lines, such as iron and metal alloy (Suliyanti et al., 2020). This is because when the laser beam directly irradiates the metal surface, the metal itself is ablated and therefore the major and minor analytical lines associated with the metal disturb the impurity and trace elemental lines, reducing the sensitivity of the technique. The other factor is the continuous background emission from the Bremsstrahlung and recombination effects (Galbács, 2015). Thus, limit of detection (LoD) of contaminants is still high.
In the other direction, we have developed various unique sampling techniques of LIBS by utilizing a pulse transversely excited atmospheric CO2 laser (Khumaeni et al., 2011; Khumaeni et al., 2010; Khumaeni et al., 2009). We noticed that compared to the Nd:YAG laser that is usually used in conventional LIBS, a pulse transversely excited atmospheric TEA CO2 laser is much more convenient for spectrochemical analysis in specific materials, such as powder samples and soft solid materials. The TEA CO2 laser can produce large volume plasma compared to the Nd:YAG laser because the TEA CO2 laser has longer wavelength or lower frequency (10 times lower than the fundamental Nd:YAG case) and longer pulse duration. Gibson et al. reported that the plasma shielding effect is much more serious for a pulsed CO2 laser because the absorption coefficient, K, due to the free-free transition of electrons can be expressed as in Eq. (1) (Gibson et al., 1971); (1) where N is the electron density in the initial plasma, ω is the frequency of the laser light, and τ is a function of the electron temperature. As is known from the equation, with decreasing frequency of laser light, the absorption coefficient increases. Therefore, when we use a TEA CO2 laser for plasma generation, the shielding effect becomes conspicuous because of its low frequency (long wavelength), resulting in large-volume plasma. We have successfully demonstrated the pulse TEA CO2 laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy for various applications, including powder analysis, softwood analysis, and surface analysis (Khumaeni et al., 2011; Khumaeni et al., 2012). It should also be noted that when a pulse CO2 laser beam is focused on a metal surface such as Cu and Ni metal plates, intense luminous plasma is produced without any ablation of the metal (Khumaeni et al., 2012; Khumaeni et al., 2020). The plasma constituent consists of elements from the surrounding gas and is not from the metal itself. This plasma is very favorable and effective as an ionization and excitation source of elements, as reported in our previous work (Khumaeni et al., 2018; Lie et al., 2011; Khumaeni et al., 2012).
Taking advantage of this phenomenon, we employed a pulse TEA CO2 laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy (TEA CO2 LIBS) for the identification and quantification of sodium contaminants in the surface of 304 stainless steel. In the present study, we propose some parameters that should be considered for the surface analysis, including a focusing-defocusing laser beam and a clean environment for samples from the other impurity. Furthermore, comparative study on this present work was also made with LIBS using a pulse Nd:YAG laser (Nd:YAG LIBS), which is commonly used in conventional LIBS, and another spectroscopic technique of inductively coupled plasma atomic emission spectroscopy (ICP-OES). A quantification of sodium contaminant in steel surfaces was successfully demonstrated using a pulse TEA CO2 LIBS, resulting in an excellent linear calibration curve of Na.
2 Experimental procedure
The experimental setup used in this study is shown in Fig. 1(a). The pulse TEA CO2 laser beam (Shibuya, 10.64 µm, 200 ns) was directed and focused by ZnSe lens with a focal length of 200 mm on a sample surface passing through the ZnSe window to induce a breakdown plasma. During data acquisition, laser energy was varied from 0.75 J to 1.5 J by placing a metal aperture in the laser beam’s path. The beam size of the laser on the sample surface was 2.25 mm2 for a laser energy of 0.75 J.
The samples used in this work were 304 steel samples containing various concentrations of Na contaminant on their surfaces, namely 25, 50, 100, and 250 mg/kg. To produce the Na contaminant on the steel surface, almost the same procedure as in a previous experiment (Khumaeni et al., 2018) was carried out. For example, to produce Na contaminant at a concentration of 50 mg/kg, which a homogeneous dilution of 110 mg of NaCl in 1000 ml of tap water was made; tap water was used because Na particles can be deposited easily on the steel surface. Then, 3 ml of the mixed Na water was poured on the surface of the steel sheet. The sheet was then heated by microwave oven for 5 min so that the Na contaminant dried completely on the sheet surface. The dimension of the Na film produced on the steel surface was 10 mm in diameter. Based on our calculation, Na concentration of 50 mg/kg on the surface of material target corresponds to 0.06 mg/cm2. Various concentrations of sodium contaminant was also confirmed by using inductively coupled plasma-atomic emission spectroscopy (ICP-OES, Agilent 700).
For LIBS experiment, the sample was placed in a chamber with a diameter and a height of 12 cm and 10 cm, respectively. During data acquisition, the sample was placed in a chamber and nitrogen gas introduced, in which the pressure was kept constant at 1 atmosphere. This condition was chosen to avoid other element impurities from the ambient air disturbing the analytical emission lines. The flow rate of the gas was 4 L per minute (Lpm).
A comparative study was also made using LIBS utilizing a Nd:YAG laser (1064 nm, 7 ns, 10 Hz, beam diameter of 3 mm, beam divergence less than 1 mrad). For Nd:YAG LIBS, the laser energy was at 83 mJ. This laser energy was selected because based on our experiment, the optimum emission intensity of sodium with lower background emission intensity was obtained using 83 mJ laser energy. Furthermore, when we reduce the laser energy, the intensity of Na also decreases; when the laser energy was increased, the intensity of sodium also increased with increasing background emission. The Nd:YAG laser beam was directly focused using a quartz lens (focal length of 100 mm) on the steel surface containing Na contaminant to produce a breakdown plasma.
The plasma emission obtained was then sent via optical fiber into an optical multichannel analyzer system (OMA ATAGO Macs 320), which consists of a 0.32 m focal length spectrograph with a grating of 1200 groves/mm, a 1024 channel photodiode detector array, to obtain the emission spectrum of sodium from the steel surface. The gate delay time and gate width of the OMA system was 10 and 100 μs, respectively. In our experimental setup, a digital delay system (SRS DG535) was used to set a gate delay time and gate width of the OMA system during data acquisition. To trigger the digital delay system, a small part of the laser beam was used by sending the beam via a photon-drag as shown in Fig. 1(a).
3 Results and discussion
First, we employed a LIBS using a pulse Nd:YAG laser for the identification of sodium contaminant on the steel surface. The sample used was 304 steel metals without any cleaning on the steel surface. To examine the contamination of sodium from the atmosphere, which generally contains Na, the steel was placed inside a Pyrex glass tube (Fig. 1(b)) and finally put inside the chamber, which was filled with N2 gas. The Pyrex was used as the sample container during data acquisition because it is overwhelmingly available in local markets and has good quality glass compared to other glass tubes. Fig. 2(a) shows the emission spectrum obtained from the 304 steel sample placed inside the glass tube. It is seen that no emission lines of neutral Na at the wavelengths of 588.9 nm and 589.6 nm are detected in the spectrum. However, some analytical lines at wavelengths of around 570–580 nm that come from the steel surface are faintly detected. This indicated that the steel itself also ablated when the Nd:YAG laser beam is directed and focused on the steel. Furthermore, the background emission is also high even the gate delay time was set at 1 μs; the background emission (continuous emission) comes from the Bremsstrahlung effect and free-bound transition. This is because the plasma induced in the metal surface still has a high temperature, even at the later stage of 1 μs of plasma emission, resulting in high background emission. When the sample was placed inside the metal chamber without the Pyrex glass tube, neutral Na emission lines at 588.9 nm and 589.6 nm faintly occurred as shown in Fig. 2(b). This Na comes from the Na contaminant deposited in the atmosphere, which still remains inside the chamber. This result certified that the use of the Pyrex glass tube is essential to avoid sodium contaminants from the atmosphere. Therefore, in this work the glass tube was used during experimental data acquisition.
To show that the Nd:YAG LIBS can be employed to identify sodium contaminant deposited on the steel surface, steel containing sodium on its surface was used as a sample. Fig. 3(a) shows the emission spectrum of Na taken from the 304 steel metal sample containing 10 mg/kg Na using Nd:YAG LIBS. High emission intensity of Na at 588.9 nm and 589.6 nm clearly occurs with quite high background emission. Furthermore, many emission lines of Fe at around 570–580 nm appear, which come from the steel. However, when the steel sample does not contain sodium contaminant on its surface, no emission lines of Na occur and only Fe emission lines appear, as shown in Fig. 3(b). It should also be noted that the ablation of steel itself happens during laser bombardment. To overcome this issue, we proposed a pulse TEA CO2 laser instead of an Nd:YAG laser as an energy source to induce a luminous plasma on the steel surface.
Prior to explaining the experimental data, it is desirable to shortly review the mechanism of plasma generation using a pulse TEA CO2 laser on metal surfaces, as reported in our previous work (Khumaeni et al., 2011; Khumaeni et al., 2012; Khumaeni et al., 2011). Compared to an Nd:YAG laser, a unique phenomenon takes place in the plasma generation using the pulse TEA CO2 laser due to its specific characteristics of long wavelength (10.6 um) and long pulse duration (200 ns). Namely, large volume and high temperature plasma is readily produced. Physically, when a hard metal plate is irradiated using a tight focus by a pulse TEA CO2 laser on its surface, electrons come out from the metal surface due to a multiphoton absorption process at the surface impinged by the laser beam. The electrons are subsequently accelerated by the electric field of laser light, which produces overwhelming ionization in the gas and finally initiates a luminous plasma. The plasma then absorbs the laser beam via free-free transition due to the inverse Bremsstrahlung. It should also be mentioned that no ablation on the surface of the metal plate occurs and only gas plasma is produced by the focusing of TEA CO2 with laser energy of 1.5 J and focal length of ZnSe lens of 200 mm.
We then apply a pulse TEA CO2 LIBS to obtain an emission spectrum from the steel surface containing Na contaminant. Fig. 4(a) displays the emission spectrum of sodium obtained from the same sample as in Fig. 3(a) using a pulse TEA CO2 LIBS. High emission intensity of neutral Na I 588.9 nm and Na I 589.6 nm is obtained with low background emission. Furthermore, no Fe lines are detected in the spectrum. This unique phenomenon only happens for the LIBS using a pulse TEA CO2 laser. Namely, when the pulse CO2 laser was focused on a metal surface, by controlling its power density on the surface, no ablation from the surface happens and only ablation from the contaminant. Thus, no Fe lines from the steel metal occur in the spectrum. When the steel sample without any sodium contaminant was used, no sodium emission lines appear as shown in Fig. 4(b). It should be noted that the emission profile of sodium lines is much better for TEA CO2 LIBS compared to the case of Nd:YAG LIBS. Namely, the emission lines of sodium have high intensity, and low background and noise level.
The present technique of TEA CO2 LIBS is then employed for the quantification of sodium on the steel surface. However, prior to this, the effect of a focused laser beam on the emission intensity of sodium was examined. Fig. 5 shows how the emission intensity of sodium taken from the steel metal containing 50 mg/kg sodium contaminant on its surface changes with the laser beam defocused. It is seen that the sodium intensity is very low under tight laser focus conditions. The intensity then increases and attains a maximum with a laser beam defocus at 4 mm. With increasing laser beam defocus, the intensity decreased and finally was almost stable up to 18 mm defocused. It should be mentioned that the defocused 18 mm focal point means that the laser is focused 18 mm in front of the focal point. Based on this result, we used 4 mm beam defocused to obtain an optimum emission intensity of sodium from the steel surface containing Na contaminant.
Finally, a quantification of sodium contaminant on a steel surface was carried out using the TEA CO2 LIBS. Fig. 6 shows the calibration curve of sodium taken from the steel surface containing various concentrations of sodium. Each data plotted in the curve is the average of five spectra. Each spectrum was taken by 20 shots of laser bombardment and the data acquisition repeated 5 times under the condition that the laser beam was defocused at the surface of the steel sample. An excellent linear calibration curve was obtained between the intensity of sodium and its concentration on the steel surface with the determination coefficient R2 of 0.98; the error bar shown in Fig. 6 represents standard deviation. Thus, this technique is applicable to the practical quantitative analysis of sodium on the steel surface.
The technique was then used to identify sodium contaminant on the surface. Fig. 7 shows the emission spectrum of sodium contaminant obtained from the steel metal containing 50 mg/kg Na on its surface. Sodium lines at 588.9 nm and 589.6 nm are clearly detected with high emission intensity and low background emission. An unidentified line at around 572 nm occurs with a broad and quite low intensity. The detection limit of sodium was estimated to be 0.5 mg/kg; the detection limit was derived from the emission line of Na by multiplying three times the noise divided by the emission intensity of sodium contaminant from the steel (Ingle and Crouch, 1988).
The sodium contaminant at various concentrations was also confirmed using inductively coupled plasma-atomic emission spectroscopy. Fig. 8 shows sodium contaminants at various concentrations obtained by using ICP-OES, which is generally used as a standard analytical technique for identification and quantification of elements in material. It is seen clearly that linear curve with intercept zero with high determination coefficient of 0.99 was obtained. This result states that the sodium used in this study can be applied as a sample target of contaminant at various concentrations in the steel surface.
4 Conclusions
Laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy using a pulse TEA CO2 laser has been employed for the identification and quantification of sodium contaminant on a steel surface. Compared to the Nd:YAG LIBS, the present technique is superior. Namely, a highly clear emission spectrum of sodium without any disturbance from analytical lines from the steel bulk was successfully produced by using TEA CO2 laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy, resulting in higher sensitivity. An excellent linear calibration curve of sodium obtained from the steel surface containing various concentrations of sodium was successfully made with an intercept at zero. The limit of detection of sodium is estimated to be 0.5 mg/kg. The present work is potentially applicable to the practical quantitative analysis of sodium on steel surfaces in the metal industry and in nuclear power reactors. By using standard analytical technique of ICP-OES, it is also confirmed that the sodium used in this study can be applied as a sample target of contaminant at various concentrations in the steel surface.
Acknowledgment
This research is funded by the Ministry of Research and Technology Indonesia under Research Grant of Word Class Research 2021 contract No.213-01/UN7.6.1/PP/2021.
Declaration of Competing Interest
The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.
References
- Selection of sodium coolant for fast reactors in the US France and Japan. Nuclear Eng. Des.. 2013;254:194-217.
- [Google Scholar]
- Burnup Performance of CANDLE Burning Reactor Using Sodium Coolant. Nucl. Sci. Eng.. 2020;194:1128-1142.
- [Google Scholar]
- A review of inherent safety characteristics of metal alloy sodium-cooled fast reactor fuel against postulated accidents. Nuclear Eng. Technol.. 2015;47:227-239.
- [Google Scholar]
- A comparative physics study for an innovative sodium-cooled fast reactor (iSFR) Int. J. Energy Res.. 2016;42:151-162.
- [Google Scholar]
- Effect of radiation-induced defects om corrosion. Ann. Rev. Mater. Res.. 2021;51:293-328.
- [Google Scholar]
- 9-Application of computational fluid dynamics in design of sodium-cooled fast reactors, Advances of Computational Fluid Dynamics in Nuclear Reactor Design and Safety. Assessment 2019:729-753.
- [Google Scholar]
- Performance evaluation of PFBR wire type sodium leak detectors. Nucl. Eng. Des.. 2011;241:2271-2279.
- [Google Scholar]
- High-Performance Differential Pressure Monitoring Devices Using Pulsating Sensors for a Sodium-Cooled Fast Breeder Reactor. Nucl. Technol.. 2017;176:127-137.
- [Google Scholar]
- Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators. Spectrometers, Detectors Associated Equipment. 2013;724:76-82.
- [Google Scholar]
- Sample treatment and preparation for laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy. Spectrochim. Acta, Part B. 2016;115:52-63.
- [Google Scholar]
- A critical review of recent progress in analytical laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy. Anal. Bioanal. Chem.. 2015;407:7537-7562.
- [Google Scholar]
- Industrial applications of laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy: a review. Anal. Methods. 2020;12:1014-1029.
- [Google Scholar]
- Accuracy improvement of quantitative analysis for major elements in laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy using single-sample calibration. Anal. Chim. Acta. 2019;1064:11-16.
- [Google Scholar]
- In Situ Underwater Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy Analysis for Trace Cr(VI) in Aqueous Solution Supported by Electrosorption Enrichment and a Gas-Assisted Localized Liquid Discharge Apparatus. Anal. Chem.. 2017;89:5557-5564.
- [Google Scholar]
- Elemental imaging using laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy: A new and promising approach for biological and medical applications. Coord. Chem. Rev.. 2018;358:70-79.
- [Google Scholar]
- Characterization of the Chinese Traditional Medicine Artemisia annua by Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy (LIBS) with 532 nm and 1064 nm Excitation. Anal. Lett.. 2020;53:922-936.
- [Google Scholar]
- Applications of laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy for geochemical and environmental analysis: A comprehensive review. Spectrochim. Acta, Part B. 2013;87:11-26.
- [Google Scholar]
- Laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy application in environmental monitoring of water quality: a review. Environ. Monit. Assess.. 2014;186:8969-8980.
- [Google Scholar]
- Su, L., Yu, H., Cong, Z., Lu, H., Cao, B., Zeng, P., Dong, W., Li, Y. Applications of laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy in the aluminum electrolysis industry, Spectrochimica Acta Part B: Atomic Spectroscopy 142, 29-36.
- Potential use of surface-assisted LIBS for determination of strontium in wines. Appl. Opt.. 2018;57:8272-8278.
- [Google Scholar]
- Comparison of excitation mechanisms and the corresponding emission spectra in femto second and nano second laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy in reduced ambient air and their performances in surface analysis. J. Laser Appl.. 2020;32:012014
- [Google Scholar]
- A unique technique of laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy using transversely excited atmospheric CO2 laser for the sensitive analysis of powder samples. Curr. Appl Phys.. 2011;11:423-427.
- [Google Scholar]
- A novel double-pulse laser plasma spectroscopic technique for H analysis in metal samples utilizing transversely excited atmospheric-pressure CO2 laser-induced metastable He atoms. Opt. Rev.. 2010;17:285-289.
- [Google Scholar]
- Analysis of organic powder samples by using the metal-assisted subtarget effect in a Transversely-Excited Atmospheric (TEA) CO2 laser-induced he gas plasma at 1 atm. Journal of The Korean Physical Society. 2009;55:2441-2446.
- [Google Scholar]
- CO2 laser generation of plasma for spectroscopy and spectrochemical analysis. J. Phys. D Appl. Phys.. 1971;4:1527-1534.
- [Google Scholar]
- Rapid analyses of tiny amounts of powder samples using transversely excited atmospheric CO2 laserinduced helium gas plasma with the aid of high-vacuum silicon grease as a binder on a metal subtarget. Appl. Spectrosc.. 2011;65:236-241.
- [Google Scholar]
- Comparative study of Nd:YAG laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy and transversely excited atmospheric CO2 laser-induced gas plasma spectroscopy on chromated copper arsenate preservative-treated wood. Appl. Opt.. 2012;51:B121-B129.
- [Google Scholar]
- Trace metal analysis of element on material surface using pulse CO2 laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy applying vaporization technique. Heliyon. 2020;6:e04670
- [Google Scholar]
- Pulsed CO2 laser-induced gas plasma spectroscopy based on single beam splitting for trace metal analysis on a material surface. J. Mod. Opt.. 2018;65:2229-2233.
- [Google Scholar]
- Excitation mechanism of H, He, C, and F atoms in metal-assisted atmospheric helium gas plasma induced by transversely excited atmospheric-pressure CO 2 laser bombardment. Jpn. J. Appl. Phys.. 2011;50:122701
- [Google Scholar]
- Emission characteristics of Ca and Mg atoms in gas plasma induced by the bombardment of transversely excited atmospheric CO 2 laser at 1 atm. Jpn. J. Appl. Phys.. 2012;51:082403
- [Google Scholar]
- Direct analysis of powder samples using transversely excited atmospheric CO2 laser-induced gas plasma at 1 atm. Anal. Bioanal. Chem.. 2011;400:3279-3287.
- [Google Scholar]
- Spectrochemical Analysis. New Jersey: Prentice Hall; 1988.
